In This Article
BetterHelp and Cerebral take different approaches to online mental health care. BetterHelp focuses purely on talk therapy with the world's largest therapist network. Cerebral combines therapy with medication management. Here's how to choose the right one.
Quick Verdict
Choose BetterHelp if: You want therapy only (no medication), need the widest therapist selection, and don't have insurance. Best for mild-moderate anxiety, depression, and life challenges.
Choose Cerebral if: You need medication alongside therapy, have in-network insurance (Aetna, BCBS, Cigna, Optum, UHC), or want a collaborative care model combining both.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | BetterHelp | Cerebral |
|---|---|---|
| Therapy | 🏆 30,000+ therapists | Available (smaller network) |
| Medication | Not available | 🏆 Prescribing + delivery |
| Insurance | Very limited | 🏆 Aetna, BCBS, Cigna, Optum, UHC |
| Price (no insurance) | $65-100/week | $60-365/month depending on plan |
| Therapist switching | 🏆 Unlimited, easy | Requires contacting support |
| Matching speed | 🏆 24 hours | Varies |
| Couples therapy | 🏆 Available | Available ($325/month) |
| Psychiatry | Not available | 🏆 Board-certified prescribers |
| Controlled substances | N/A | ❌ Not prescribed |
| Financial aid | 🏆 Available (up to 50% off) | Veteran discount (15%) |
Pricing Comparison
| Plan | BetterHelp | Cerebral |
|---|---|---|
| Therapy only | $65-100/week | $175/session |
| Medication only | N/A | $60/month (quarterly billing) |
| Therapy + medication | N/A | $365/month |
| With insurance | Limited coverage | ~$30 copay/session |
Key takeaway: BetterHelp is typically cheaper for therapy-only needs. But if you need medication AND your insurance covers Cerebral, it could be significantly cheaper overall.
Who Should Choose Which?
Choose BetterHelp if:
- You want therapy only — no medication needed
- Ease of switching therapists matters to you
- You don't have insurance or your insurance doesn't cover Cerebral
- You want the largest selection of therapists and specialisations
- Mild-moderate anxiety, depression, or stress are your concerns
Choose Cerebral if:
- You need medication alongside therapy
- Your insurance covers Cerebral (Aetna, BCBS, Cigna, Optum, UHC)
- You want the collaborative care model (prescriber + therapist working together)
- You prefer having medication delivered to your door
- Note: Cerebral cannot prescribe controlled substances (no Adderall, Xanax, etc.)
Also consider Talkspace — it offers therapy + psychiatry with broader insurance coverage than Cerebral.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is cheaper, BetterHelp or Cerebral?
BetterHelp is cheaper for therapy only ($65-100/week vs $175/session). Cerebral is cheaper for medication management ($60/month). With insurance covering Cerebral, therapy could be as low as $30/session.
Can Cerebral prescribe ADHD medication?
No. Cerebral stopped prescribing controlled substances (stimulants like Adderall, benzodiazepines like Xanax) following a 2022 investigation. Only non-stimulant options are available for ADHD.
Does BetterHelp accept insurance?
BetterHelp has very limited insurance coverage in select states. For insurance-covered therapy, Talkspace or Cerebral are better options.
Should I combine online therapy with meditation?
Absolutely. Meditation between therapy sessions reinforces skills and accelerates progress. Many therapists actively recommend meditation apps alongside treatment.
